Lasted longer than expected!
Bought this wallet in October 2012, this week it finally ripped. For claiming 4-5 years of use, I think I did pretty good!
I might buy the same model, or perhaps a different one, but I'm pretty sold on Big Skinny overall.
ProsI have it stuffed with 20+ cards and it never complained.
ConsThe coating on the inside of the bill compartment didn't last very long